Get on the team

What Are Substack Pledges & Should You Enable Them?

Substack pledges vs paid subscriptions, benefits and drawbacks

Substack Pledges are a feature on the Substack platform that allows readers to pledge their support for a writer’s newsletter before paid subscriptions are enabled. This innovative tool serves multiple purposes – it gauges audience interest, provides confidence for creators to eventually charge, and readies an initial subscriber base for when payments go live.

What are Substack Pledges?

First, if you’re completely new to Substack or have never heard of the platform, here is a comprehensive review of what Substack can and cannot do:

Now, back to the topic.

Substack Pledges enable readers to promise future financial support for a newsletter they enjoy. It allows subscribers to pick a monthly or yearly pledge tier and enter payment details, signaling their willingness to pay when the writer decides to activate paid subscriptions.

This preemptive pledge serves as an informal commitment from fans who see value in the creator’s work. By pledging, audiences demonstrate their eagerness to financially contribute to the newsletter once the option is made available.

The pledges are essentially non-binding promises conveying readers’ intent to subscribe. No payment is processed at the point of pledge – it is merely an expression of support and prepays future subscription fees when enabled.

The Origin and Concept Behind Pledges

Substack introduced Pledges in December 2022 to help writers understand audience demand before committing to paid subscriptions. It was designed to address the uncertainty creators face regarding whether their readers will pay.

Pledges serve as a bridge between free newsletters and paid models. They allow creators to gauge subscriber interest and get a taste of revenue potential prior to paywalling their content.

For supporters, it offers a way to signal their appreciation for creators and influence the decision to charge for access. Pledges cultivate a relationship where subscribers play a role in financially sustaining newsletters they find valuable.

How Substack Pledges Work

The Pledges system functions through prompts displayed to readers at multiple touchpoints. When enabled by creators, new subscribers see a pledge option immediately after signing up, requesting contributions before seeing any posts.

Existing subscribers encounter occasional prompts within the newsletter and on the homepage inviting them to pledge future support. They select a monthly or yearly tier and enter payment details, completing a provisional transaction.

These pledges remain inactive until creators activate paid subscriptions, at which point pledged subscribers are automatically converted and charged accordingly. This allows writers to transition seamlessly while leveraging their pledged base.

Setting Up Pledges as a Creator

Substack automatically enables Pledges for all free newsletters, so creators must manually disable it if undesired. The feature can be managed under Settings > Payments.

To set up Pledges, creators pick pledge tier values, with minimums of $5 monthly and $50 yearly. Monthly, yearly, and founding member tiers can be customized to offer readers options.

Once enabled, Pledges work automatically through prompts. Writers receive notifications when new pledges are made and can track them under Stats.

The Benefits of Substack Pledges

For Creators

  • Gives insight into potential earning from subscribers
  • Allows gauging audience willingness to pay
  • Readies initial paying subscriber base for paywall
  • Provides confidence to switch to paid model

For Supporters

  • Allows supporting creators financially in the future
  • Helps influence creator’s decision to charge
  • Signals appreciation without upfront payment

For Community

  • Strengthens writer-reader relationships
  • Fosters invested, engaged subscriber base
  • Enables supporters to shape content landscape

Considerations Before Enabling Pledges

The utility of Pledges depends on a newsletter’s goals. It is best suited for creators focused on building engaged communities versus driving indirect monetization.

Pledges may be counterproductive for marketing-oriented newsletters aimed at promoting other revenue streams. Creators should ensure content quality and explain their aims before seeking pledges.

Managing supporter expectations around delivery of pledged rewards can also be challenging. Clear communication of pledge benefits and limitations is key.

Turning On Payments After Pledges

Once creators decide to implement paid subscriptions, pledged subscribers are automatically converted and charged based on their pledge tier. This seamless transition leverages the provisional buy-in from supporters.

If subscription prices are set higher than pledge amounts, creators can choose to honor original pledge values or request additional payment from subscribers. Emails inform pledged subscribers of changes.

The pledged subscriber base forms the initial revenue stream when payments go live. Pledges lay the groundwork for monetization and remove uncertainty around its viability.

Promoting Your Substack Pledge Campaign

An effective promotional strategy helps maximize Pledges’ benefits. Creators should communicate the value proposition of their newsletter and the utility of pledging to ready audiences for future paid plans.

Leveraging social media, personalized interactions with readers, exclusive content sneak peeks for pledgers, and collaborations with other creators can also raise visibility and interest.

Tailored messaging for each platform combined with strategically used hashtags, ads, and incentives helps expand reach and encourage contributions.

The Future of Subscription Content and Pledges

Substack Pledges align with growing consumer willingness to pay for quality digital content and closer direct creator relationships. The model reflects predictions of expanded content monetization via subscription-style fan funding.

As creators like journalists, writers, podcasters, and newsletter publishers transition to paid models, Pledges offer an innovative way to validate viability, build investor confidence, and smooth the path to sustainability.

By enabling audiences to influence the financial trajectory of creators, models like Pledges could continue reshaping how creators diversify income streams while remaining audience-focused.

Substack Pledges provide an effective, minimally disruptive way for newsletter creators to test subscriber willingness to pay. Pledges allow readers to signal their appreciation and value for writers’ work prior to paid content plans. This not only readies revenue potential but strengthens bonds between creators and their community.

Recent Posts

Learn How to Write For Money

From someone who makes money writing ↓

Dive into the life of a full-time content creator with me. And get ALL my digital products for free. Just sign up 👌

From my store

Creators’ Toolbox